Ice Cream Shop - 2011 Winners

Published May 12, 2011

Banana splits, waffle cones are fun, but it's all about the ice cream. Who's got the best?

2011 Winner

1. Banana's Ice Cream Cafe

Voters Love

"Reminds you of an older style icecream parlor...right down to the black and white tiles floors but has all the modern..."  via Kelli M.

Find It
400 E Lincoln Ave Wildwood NJ 08260
2011 Runner-Up

2. Cool Scoops

Voters Love

"Because Cool Scoops is the best ice cream parlor in town. The staff is very polite and they have the best entertainment..." 

Find It
1111 New Jersey Ave Wildwood NJ 08260
2011 Finalist

3. Barry's Do Me A Flavor

Voters Love

"Barry's is the best ice cream shop with the best people and environment. I grew up there and miss it every day!"  via Jennifer M.

Find It
309 Centre St Beach Haven NJ 08008
2011 Finalist

4. Marcella's Caffe and Gelateria

Voters Love

"My steph mom makes the best gelato... i mean seriously its so good it has to be better than what they make in italy!! love..."  via Danielle C.

Find It
6111 New Jersey Ave Wildwood Crest NJ 08260
2011 Finalist

5. The Windmill

Voters Love

"the BEST for SO many reasons! amazing ice cream, even better waffles, and the thickest, creamiest shakes in town! all served..."  via Maria A.

Find It
9th & Bay Ave Beach Haven NJ 08008
Contest Overview
  • 16,608
    Total Votes
  • 6,535
  • 77

The 2011 Jersey Shore HOT LIST awards are based on more than 16,000 votes from local Jersey Shore-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the phl17 Jersey Shore HOT LIST
Arts and Entertainment
Health and Beauty
Specialty Food and Drink
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
The phl17 Jersey Shore HOT LIST features more than 1,347 businesses competing for title of Jersey Shore's best.

Connect with phl17 Jersey Shore HOT LIST